TMA this month

Hostility to women in Melbourne diocese?

Wednesday, 16 Jun 2010, by Anglican Media

talking point speech bubble

Men lead, women obey?

There is a growing backlash against women being treated as equals in churches around Australia, with some women being pressured not to become priests. Barney Zwartz reports on the battle looming. [The Age]
Barney Zwartz has written a long article quoting the experience of people from both sides of the debate in Melbourne.

Previously:


Numbers of young men now being ordained are hostile to women in ministry, according to the Revd Dr Kevin Giles.

"...In earlier years, Evangelicals in Melbourne had been leaders in support for women's ordination through the advocacy of Ridley College principal, Bible scholar Leon Morris. But since 1995, the atmosphere had changed significantly, Dr Giles told a meeting at St Mark's, Templestowe last month ...

... The view that God had put men in charge of the church and the home had increased in recent years, he said. The strategy of not mentioning it in the hope that the opposition to women would go away had meant that the situation has just got worse, he added.

But the church was healthier when men and women shared leadership, said Dr Giles, a retired Melbourne vicar and scholar who has written extensively in support of women's full equality.

Dr Giles said that ordination was just the tip of the iceberg, as he outlined his concern for the damage that could be done through the view that men should be "head" of the home.

"In the home this teaching can encourage men to be selfish, or even to abuse their wives," he explained. "Percentage-wise, there is more abuse in the home in churches that teach male headship.""

Read the rest of the story here.

The article prompted a strong response from our readers. "The current new wave of anti-women clergy puts the Church at odds with moves in society to treat women equally with men at work, at home and in public life," says Alan Nichols in our Readers' Letters this month. However, Clare Rogers, Chair of the Board of Ridley College, says "Ridley Melbourne is proud to be associated with leading women in ministry".

You can have your say below. Please be respectful and courteous in your conversation. Comments are moderated and may take some time to appear.

Read full story with links.

The case for God

Wednesday, 31 Mar 2010, by Anglican Media

CaseforGod_cross_against_sun

Melbourne will be hosting a global atheists' convention in March.

In this month's special TMA supplement, "The Case For God," Dorothy Lee presents key arguments from Rowan Williams’ commentary on the Creeds, Tokens of Trust; Alister McGrath responds to Richard Dawkins; Roy Williams, author of God, Actually, considers how science supports faith in God; and Colin Goodwin outlines Aquinas’ arguments for the existence of God.

In addition, Andrew McGowan and Peter Adam profile two ‘Heroes of the Faith’, and Roland Ashby reflects on the problem of suffering.

What do you think? Has the case been made adequately? How would you make the case? Do you think it needs to be made?

Have your say by clicking "post a comment" below. Comments are moderated, and may take some time to appear on our site. Abusive, attacking or otherwise inappropriate content will not be published.

More reading on our site:
Other sites:

Read full story with links.

Empty ritual or outreach?

Friday, 5 Dec 2008, by Anglican Media

talking point speech bubble

Weddings, funerals and baptisms are often times of tension between liturgical integrity and generous evangelism and hospitality. How can this be resolved? 


Background:

  • Baptism requirement a ‘barrier’ to marriage ministry
    Synod assented to a provisional canon of General Synod which seeks to amend the requirement for at least one of the bride and groom to be baptised for their wedding to be conducted by an Anglican Minister.
  • Letters in response to Dr Muriel Porters' The Death of the Funeral, TMA Nov:

    Empty ritual

    I was moved by Muriel Porter’s article, The death of the funeral (TMA, November) and her recognition of the emptiness of a secular funeral service. However, it’s not the loss of religious trappings and ritual that distresses me, but the loss of a living, transforming faith in Jesus Christ in whose name such services are conducted. The hypocrisy of a funeral with all the Anglican words and rituals, but without trust in Jesus lived out in obedience and love, can be more distressing than a completely secular funeral.

    Dr Porter mourns that the church has lost its role as “custodian of our society’s rites of passage”. The symbolism and rituals and tradition of the Christian faith are worthless if there is no meaningful, living faith underpinning them. When people look at church-goers and fail to see that Christianity makes any difference to their lives, is it any wonder that they do not find religion attractive?

    Fiona McLean
    Mont Albert North

    Funerals lose focus

    Muriel Porter’s description of the secular funeral she experienced (TMA November 2008) could, with little real difference, be applied to what happens in many of our churches. There too she will find sentimental claptrap, inappropriate eulogies, mawkish doggerel and an overall focus on the life of the deceased rather than what is essentially the principal focus of Christian funerals – the promise of eternal life in Jesus Christ. Ministers really need to decide whether they are simply customers of the funeral industry, captive to the sentiments of the bereaved, or representatives of a faith that acknowledges the reality of death but not its ultimate victory.

    Hugh McGinlay
    Thornbury

What is your experience of this issue? How is a compromise reached? How far does pragmatism have to go? Have your say by clicking "post a comment" below. Comments are moderated and may take some time to appear.

Read full story with links.

November TMA out now

Monday, 12 Nov 2007, by Anglican Media

tma front cover small nov 07

All November's online stories can be found here. TMA covered a lot of General Synod stuff this month, but because we'd already published it on the General Synod blog, I haven't reproduced it on the TMA site. But feel free to discuss all the General Synod news here anyway!

To leave your comment, please click "post comment" below. Comments are moderated, so it may take a little while for yours to appear. Don't forget to check back! To be automatically updated, you can get a news feed straight to your computer.


Read full story with links.

TMA October 2007

Monday, 8 Oct 2007, by Anglican Media

tma front cover small

All the stories online this month

Subscribe securely online.

October's TMA is online with a selection of our stories. Have your say on any of our articles this month - just click the "post comment" link below. Comments are moderated so they may take a little while to appear.

You can still comment on any of our previous stories.


Read full story with links.

Quick Links

  1. Get live news feeds

Also this month

  1. Election wish list comes from church agencies

    3 Aug 2010
    Church agencies have urged political parties contesting the 21 August Federal Election to give priority to areas as diverse as mental health, a just society and school chaplaincy.
  2. Coutsouvelis front page

    Hoppers crossing couple foster a spirit of care

    3 Aug 2010
    In 36 years of marriage, Nadine and Speros Coutsouvelishave cared for three of their own children, adopted seven children, and have fostered more than 200 others.
  3. Reactions mixed on refugee plan

    3 Aug 2010
    The Australian Christian Lobby has welcomed tougher policies on people smuggling from both sides of politics, but refugee advocates are not so pleased.
  4. +Garry 2

    Outback Anglicans need help, says bush bishop

    3 Aug 2010
    As life in the bush gets tougher by the year, the Anglican Church's "bush bishops" are working hard to ensure the church can still offer a vital lifeline to country people.
  5. werribee youth

    Youth worship in a multitude of tongues

    3 Aug 2010
    "From every nation, tribe, people and language" say the words from the eschatological vision of St John recorded in the Book of Revelation. A somewhat more modest gathering occurred to "worship the Lamb" in a multitude of different tongues on 29 May at St Thomas', Werribee, and another gathering is planned for 9 October at St Alban's, West Coburg.